Learning Center
We keep you up to date on the latest tax changes and news in the industry.
Attorney Challenges IRS to Recognize Dog as Dependent
If you've ever reviewed your pet’s veterinary bills, grooming expenses, daycare charges, and special dietary needs only to muse, "Surely, this creature qualifies as my dependent," you're not alone. In an intriguing legal move, one lawyer is championing this argument in a federal court.
In December 2025, Attorney Amanda Reynolds, practicing in New York, launched a lawsuit against the IRS, requesting official recognition of her eight-year-old golden retriever, Finnegan, as a dependent for federal tax considerations.
The case, though unconventional and bordering on surreal, touches on a legitimate question taxpayers often ponder: Are pet expenses deductible? If not, why?
This article delves into the case's details, the prevailing tax regulations, and the limited conditions under which the IRS permits tax advantages associated with animals.
The Litigation: Does My Dog Qualify?
In her legal appeal, Reynolds contends that Finnegan fulfills the IRS's definition of a dependent because:
he resides with her full-time,
he lacks income, and
she shoulders more than half of his sustenance with expenses exceeding $5,000 annually for provisions like food, healthcare, and daycare.
A national news article capturing the lawsuit highlights Reynolds' argument, asserting, "In every meaningful sense, Finnegan parallels a daughter and qualifies as a ‘dependent.’"
Reynolds also raises constitutional claims, accusing current regulations of unjust species-based discrimination (an Equal Protection challenge), and argues that the absence of tax recognition is an inappropriate "taking" under the Fifth Amendment.
Current Status of the Case
The case is presently lodged in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York and is somewhat on pause.
A federal magistrate has sanctioned a motion to stay discovery (halting the exchange of evidence) while the IRS formulates a dismissal motion.
In the court’s formal order, the judge deems the lawsuit as raising a "novel yet pressing issue" regarding whether domestic pets should be designated as "dependents" per the tax code. However, the ruling acknowledges significant obstacles, deeming the claims "inherently meritless" and unlikely to overcome a dismissal motion.
In essence: this lawsuit is indeed active and noteworthy, yet the judiciary is transparently skeptical about its prospects for success.
Why Pets Don’t Qualify as Dependents Under Tax Law
The core challenge for this lawsuit lies in the tax law's definition of dependents as “individuals.”
Per Internal Revenue Code Section 152, a dependent refers to a “qualifying child” or a “qualifying relative,” with the statute persistently applying the term “individual” in a manner historically interpreted as referring to human beings.
Thus, IRS forms and guidelines lack any provisions for listing a pet as a dependent. Dependents are individuals possessing Social Security numbers or other taxpayer identification credentials, with associated benefits—both credits and deductions—stitched around human familial and domestic links.
Although Reynolds argues that Finnegan satisfies the functional dependency attributes (residency, financial dependency, lack of income), the delineation within federal tax legislation doesn’t accommodate animals as dependent “individuals.”
Potential Tax Breaks Available for Animals
While you typically cannot deduct customary pet expenses, some exceptions provide noteworthy insights which may appeal to readers seeking practical fiscal advice.
1) Medical Deductions for Service Animals
Costs for a service animal trained to assist in managing disabilities may be deductible as medical expenses when itemizing deductions.
The IRS specifies that deductible medical expenses must exceed the specific AGI threshold when itemized. Here, expenses related to acquiring, training, and maintaining a service animal could be eligible if directly linked to medical care.
Important clarification for readers: Under federal regulations, emotional support animals are not equivalent to service animals; service animals undergo specific training for tasks linked to a disability.
2) Animals Deductible as Business Expenses
In some scenarios, animals can represent a valid business component—consider:
a guard dog tasked with safeguarding a business’s property, or
animals employed for pest control within company premises.
In these cases, particular ongoing expenses might constitute standard and essential business expenses. (Proper documentation and legitimate business purpose are vital.)
Your source document highlights this as a narrow category within which the IRS permits animal-related deductions.
3) Foster Animals and Charitable Deductions
Taxpayers nurturing foster animals for eligible agencies may deduct certain non-reimbursed costs as charitable donations—once again, strict conditions and documentation are required.
Conclusion for Taxpayers
Reynolds’ lawsuit resonates emotionally: pets are indeed family to many, and their costs are significant. However, tax legislation remains governed by statute, not sentiment.
Currently:
Pets cannot be claimed as dependents on federal tax returns.
Ordinary pet expenses (diet, grooming, general vet care for typical pets) are mostly personal and non-deductible.
Certain costs related to animals can be deducted under specific circumstances—service animals, certain business uses, and occasionally foster-related charitable expenses.
The ongoing Reynolds case is worth observing—not out of expectation for IRS recognition of pets as dependents, but because it brings into focus the profound emotional and financial reliance many households exhibit towards their pets, juxtaposed with the tax code’s clear demarcation between "family" and "property."
Moreover, it reinforces an essential reminder: before assuming certain expenses are deductible, take the time to verify IRS guidelines and recognition.
Want tax & accounting tips and insights?
Sign up for our newsletter.
Get Started Today
Book a free discovery call and let us show you how our expertise can save you money in the long run.